The way we figure it, there have been 10 generations of Mustangs. And within each generation, there's one version of the Mustang that stands out above the rest as the most emblematic of the breed. Not always the fastest or quickest, mind you, but the one that's the quintessential Mustang of its era. And the one that looks best today, exactly 45 years after the first Mustang was introduced.
So here are the top 10 Mustangs of all time; one from each generation of the pony car.
Our only apology is for the Mustang II King Cobra. To explain ourselves, all the other Mustang IIs were even worse than the King Cobra.
First Generation (1964.5-1966): 1966 Shelby GT350 -- There's a case to be made that the original Mustang Convertible is still the single most iconic Mustang of all time, but it's simply impossible to deny that the GT350 was the best of the bunch. With its Shelby-tweaked suspension and free-revving 306-horsepower 289 V8, the GT350 is simply one of the best driving cars built during the '60s. And the 1966 version with its Plexiglass rear quarter windows and functional side air extractors was the best looking.
Second Generation (1967-'68): 1968 GT390 -- Yes, Ford built some second-generation Mustangs powered by the 427 and 428 Cobra Jet engines, but so few they're really oddities more than regular production cars. And while the Shelby name was now on both GT350 and GT500 models, the cars were gaudily decorated, tuned softer to attract luxury buyers, and by '68 even Carroll Shelby had lost interest to the extent that production moved from his shop in California to the A.O. Smith Company in Michigan. The heart and soul of the second-generation Mustang is the '68 GT 390 with its 325-horsepower, 390-cubic inch V8, unadorned fastback exterior and comfortable interior. And it didn't hurt that Steve McQueen drove one in Bullitt.
Third Generation (1969-'70): 1970 Boss 302 -- The 1970 Boss 302 lays claim to mantle of the greatest of the third-generation Mustangs simply because this is the car that won the hotly contested 1970 SCCA Trans Am title. With drivers Parnelli Jones and George Follmer behind the wheel, and Bud Moore handling the wrenches, the Boss 302 was simply brilliant on track. And as a street car, the 290-horsepower Boss 302 was the best-handling Mustang made until that time. Sure the Mach 1 could be had with a 360-horsepower 428 Cobra Super Jet engine under its hood. And the mighty Boss 429 Mustang is a legend of its own, but it's the Boss 302 that was the best balanced and the Mustang that won races.
Fourth Generation (1971-'73): 1971 Boss 351 -- The Mustang grew porcine with the introduction of the '71 models. In fact, these Mustangs were so porky that they lost much of the light feel that had made Mustangs so engaging. But for just the 1971 model year, buyers could get the 350-horsepower Boss 351 Mustang. which combined big power with a relatively refined chassis.
Fifth Generation (1974-'78): 1978 King Cobra -- With its delicate Pinto-derived chassis, strangled engines, awkward styling and crummy build quality, there's not much to be said in favor of the pitiful Mustang II. The over-the-top styling of the 1978 King Cobra, however, had the virtue of total wack-job nuttiness. Featuring every styling cliche known to '70s man, it was almost possible to forget that the 302 V8 under the hood wheezed out only 139 horsepower.
Sixth Generation (1979-'93): 1987 GT 5.0 -- The "Fox body" Mustang was in production for a staggering 15 years and included such delightful cars as the Mustang SVO. But it was the 1987 GT with the 5.0-liter V8 engine, improved cylinder heads and advanced electronic fuel injection system that make the "5.0" a car easy to hot rod and easy to race. The 5.0-liter engine may have been rated at only 225 horsepower, but racers around the world would soon have it pumping out four times that much.
Seventh Generation (1994-'98): 1996 SVT Cobra -- The "SN95" Mustang was a thorough update of the previous Fox body Mustang and a significantly improved car. And it was even better when tuned by Ford's SVT division as the Cobra. But though the Cobra was offered in 1994 and '95 powered by a version of the old 5.0-liter OHV V8, it didn't really hit its stride until the introduction of the DOHC, 32-valve version of the 4.6-liter modular V8 was installed for 1996. With 305 hp available, the '96 SVT Cobra was athletic in a way no previous Mustang had ever been.
Eighth Generation (1999-2004): 2003 SVT Cobra -- Throw an intercooled Eaton supercharger atop the DOHC 32-valve 4.6-liter modular V8 and the result is 390 thundering horsepower. Back it with a six-speed manual transmission and throw in the first independent rear suspension ever installed in a production Mustang, and the 2003 SVT Cobra stands out as one of the best-handling and quickest Mustangs ever.
Ninth Generation (2005-'09): 2008 Bullitt -- Sure the supercharged 500-horsepower Shelby GT500 and 540-hp GT500 KR were both much quicker than the Bullitt, but both suffered from nose-heaviness and less-than-stellar chassis tuning. Meanwhile, the 315-hp Bullitt's 4.6-liter SOHC, three-valve engine may not be supercharged, but is eager to please and fun to romp with. And the Bullitt's chassis is both responsive and easy to live with. Plus, the Bullitt cost a lot less money.
Tenth Generation (2010-Current): 2010 GT 500 -- The GT500 is blistering fast, but it's the regular 315-horsepower GT that is the most improved Mustang. It's quicker, better-handling and bargain priced. Everything everyone wants in a Mustang. -- John Pearley Huffman, Contributor
firstwagon says:
02:07 PM, 04/17/09
I would swap the SVT models (7th and 8th generation) for the GT model. Much cheaper and almost as good. It's always risky to overprice a Mustang as it's basic roots start to shine through too brightly.
The core to the Mustang has always been a heathy dose of muscle and a huge dose of character at a price any blue collar working guy can afford.
estreka says:
03:18 PM, 04/17/09
Replace the 9th Gen Bullitt with the Rousch Mustang with the improved rear end and I think you've got yourself a proper list.
greenpony says:
03:59 PM, 04/17/09
Mmm... Terminator. The only factory Mustang ever to have IRS.
Although reading your test of the '10 GT500 has me wanting one.
lvranger says:
04:49 PM, 04/17/09
Thanks for the memories. I learned to drive on a 1996 and my first car was a 1980. I switched to pickups after that but i've always loved Mustangs. The new ones (9th and 10th on your list) represent the classics like never before, I can't wait to pick one up.
vq356mt says:
05:14 PM, 04/17/09
Always a fan of the 2000 Cobra R
threem says:
05:22 PM, 04/19/09
To be fair, there was more Falcon in the original Mustang than Pinto in the Mustang 2, plus they had better suspensions. They get more ire than they deserve.
threem says:
05:23 PM, 04/19/09
To be fair, there was more Falcon in the original Mustang than Pinto in the Mustang 2, plus they had better suspensions. They get more ire than they deserve.
threem says:
05:24 PM, 04/19/09
sorry for the double post, I got an error the first time
andersendl says:
11:50 AM, 04/20/09
Mustang fanatics will argue all day long (and then some) about this list, but as it is it's probably okay. Except for one nit: The 68 Mustang "GT390" never really existed.
All you Mustang "experts" out there correct me on this if I'm wrong, but this car really never existed as a separate version of the '68 Mustang. In other words, Ford never offered a separate version named "GT390". The 390 cu. in. engine was available as an engine option, and it also came with the "GTA" package ("A" stood for "automatic") which was available in '67, so this is probably where the confusion comes from.
Anyway, the 390 motor was never considered a real high performance motor. It was a "boat anchor" compared to Ford's 427 "side oiler" or a 396 Chevy. The only real high performance motor Ford offered as a factory option in the '67-'68 Mustang (aside from a handful of special order 427s) was the 428 Cobra Jet that debuted mid-year in the '68 model.
Therefore, I'd vote for the 428 CJ-equipped '68 as the pinnacle for the '67-'68 generation Mustang, and not the so-called "GT390".
32v says:
09:44 PM, 01/ 7/10
I've owned several of the mustangs listed in this review. Best by far is the 03 04 svt cobra. Stock block and contents can handle and live longterm with 700rwhp output that is achieved for less money than likely anyother production vehicle ever built. The irs combined with enhanced supercharging, as in my case a whipple running 17lbs. of boost, some chasis solidification and some easy weight reduction, for the $ it is in my opinion king of all mustangs ever produced. The cobra's 32valve V8 is a robust piece that is easily modified and tuned, far more entertaining than any two or three valve motor.
32v says:
09:45 PM, 01/ 7/10
I've owned several of the mustangs listed in this review. Best by far is the 03 04 svt cobra. Stock block and contents can handle and live longterm with 700rwhp output that is achieved for less money than likely anyother production vehicle ever built. The irs combined with enhanced supercharging, as in my case a whipple running 17lbs. of boost, some chasis solidification and some easy weight reduction, for the $ it is in my opinion king of all mustangs ever produced. The cobra's 32valve V8 is a robust piece that is easily modified and tuned, far more entertaining than any two or three valve motor.
32v says:
09:47 PM, 01/ 7/10
I've owned several of the mustangs listed in this review. Best by far is the 03 04 svt cobra. Stock block and contents can handle and live longterm with 700rwhp output that is achieved for less money than likely anyother production vehicle ever built. The irs combined with enhanced supercharging, as in my case a whipple running 17lbs. of boost, some chasis solidification and some easy weight reduction, for the $ it is in my opinion king of all mustangs ever produced. The cobra's 32valve V8 is a robust piece that is easily modified and tuned, far more entertaining than any two or three valve motor.