You may have noticed some changes here are the LTRTB. Cars are coming and going. In the past few weeks we've sold our Chevy Volt and have returned the Acura TSX Sport Wagon, Honda Odyssey Touring, Hyundai Equus Signature, Mini Cooper S Countryman All4, Mitsubishi Outlander Sport SE, Infiniti M56 and Nissan Juke SL AWD back home to their respective manufacturers. Plus, next Tuesday marks the end of our year long test of our Kia Optima SX.
Wrap ups on all of these 12 month tests are on the way, starting with the Mitsubishi Outlander Sport this Friday.
And we have new cars coming. Lots of them.
The cars we've ordered and are waiting patiently for are a Subaru Impreza, Toyota Prius Plug-in, Hyundal Veloster Turbo, VW Beetle Turbo, Jeep Grand Cherokee SRT8, Infiniti JX and a Mitsubishi i.
But we also have some money in the bank, and our trigger finger is getting itchy. But what should be buy?
Right now our choices are a Chevy Malibu Eco, a Lexus GS350 F Sport, a BMW 328i and a Land Rover Evoque.
What do you think? Got any better ideas?
Scott Oldham, Editor in Chief
frazier500 says:
11:54 AM, 02/15/12
Get the Evoque, since you've failed to have a Land Rover since the LR3 so many years ago. I'd personally like to see an LR4 too, but the Lexus GS350 is more important.
HOW ABOUT A JAGUAR?!
dinobot666 says:
11:54 AM, 02/15/12
I know this might sound kind of crazy, but I'd like to see a Scion iQ in the fleet. I know it's a city car, so I'd like to actually see it be used as a city car and see what drawbacks and advantages of owning a true city car is.
While I like BMWs, I'm kind of sick of reading about them on here. If you do get an Evoque, take it and the BMW X3 off-roading together and show what they can actually do, or not do off-road. Please.
agnh says:
11:56 AM, 02/15/12
Ford Focus SE sport pkg 5spd as soon as they have the upcoming Mytouch upgrade.
lowprofile says:
11:59 AM, 02/15/12
Jaguar XF please.
Also please consider:
Lexus CT200h
New CR-V
Acura TL
Porsche Panamera
Any Aston Martin :)
duck87 says:
11:59 AM, 02/15/12
Get a Dodge Charger as well.
boobylortez says:
12:00 PM, 02/15/12
I'm seriously in the market for a regular Grand Cherokee so that would've been nice, but I know MT and AW already had one last year. The SRT-8 will be fun to follow, though.
Definitely leave room for a new Escape when it comes out. How about either the Chevy or Ford half-ton diesel pickup? You need a truck.
Boxster Spyder?
I'll keep thinking...
andreweku says:
12:01 PM, 02/15/12
It's not the newest car out there anymore, but I really wanted to see a 2012 Ford Focus added to the fleet, specifically one with the dual-clutch auto. I'd be very interested in finding out if the PowerShift is as much of a pain as everyone makes it out to be, and if the rest of the car makes up for it. I think it would be an interesting addition.
ctpaul says:
12:01 PM, 02/15/12
I know it would be another VW (you have two now with the Beetle?) but how about the new Passat? New car, new plant.... Enough with the BMW's, not interested in the Evoque. Malibu ehhh. Ford Focus Titanium (or whatever it is called) with the stick?
boobylortez says:
12:07 PM, 02/15/12
Jaguar XJ. Give the A8 some competition.
rl5 says:
12:08 PM, 02/15/12
do not get a 328i. Charger/300, Focus, Malibu ECO, GS350 sound good for now. In the future ATS and Dart are no brainers.
badreligion says:
12:10 PM, 02/15/12
An Audi A6. I just picked one up, and I would like to see how it compares to your A8L, considering it is about half the price.
jasond52 says:
12:11 PM, 02/15/12
Jag please.
throwback says:
12:11 PM, 02/15/12
Of the cars mentioned I would go with the Evoque 2 door or the Lexus GS. However I think the Mazda CX5 needs to be on your list. Mazda is betting the farm on skyactiv (awful name by the way) and are even willing to license it. I want to know if it is all it's cracked to be, and the Cx5 is the first car developed from the ground up with skyactiv tech. As for the Bug, why not go with the 2.5? We know the turbo 2.0 is a sweet engine, but is the 2.5 really such a bad engine?
jojogovroom says:
12:11 PM, 02/15/12
Get a Land Rover Evoque. It has won numerous awards and it would be good to see if those awards are warranted.
roadburner says:
12:12 PM, 02/15/12
Of the incoming cars I look forward to reading about the SRT-8 and Veloster Turbo. I'd like to see the Evoque. Wait on the Focus and get an ST.
boobylortez says:
12:12 PM, 02/15/12
Project Trans Am!!!
legacygt says:
12:13 PM, 02/15/12
While I think you owe it to yourselves to benchmark the new 3 Series (since it is the sedan against which so many others are judged) you should not spend your money on it because you seem to get BMWs loaned to you all the time. Get the Evoq, it's something different. Get the GS, I don't care that much about it but it's a significant change from it's predecessor. +1 on the Focus, especially while the Mazda3 is in the fleet for comparison. Word is that the Malibu ECO is a fail but you could use another mid-size sedan...maybe wait till the standard Malidbu comes out.
jchan2 says:
12:14 PM, 02/15/12
Cars I'd Like to See:
Honda CR-V/Acura RDX
Range Rover Evoque
Acura ILX
Jaguar XJ
Dodge Durango
i_s says:
12:15 PM, 02/15/12
Get a Scion FRS/Subaru BRZ as soon as they are available. (hopefully in couple month)
subytrojan says:
12:19 PM, 02/15/12
2013 Ford Focus ST, 2013 Ford Fusion
autoboy1 says:
12:21 PM, 02/15/12
@throwback
The 2.5 is a decent engine. It's a bit course and lacks fuel economy compared to new engines. It will be replaced with a 1.8L turbo in a lot of VW's cars so I don't see much point in doing a test on one. I'm not sure I see a point in doing a Beetle since it is likely to be much like the GTI, but ok. I guess you get them for free.
I would like to see the 328i followed up by an ATS 6 months later.
The Evoque could be really interesting so I vote for that too.
Someone mentioned a Passat. I think they should wait a year until the 1.8t arrives and then give it a spin. The diesel has been written about a lot, and the VR6 isn't a volume model but would be fun.
govango says:
12:21 PM, 02/15/12
I make a strong vote for the Lexus GS 350.
Major upgrade, great early reviews, design indicator for future Lexus models.
pumpkinfish says:
12:21 PM, 02/15/12
I'm thinking Dodge Charger/Chrysler 300. Maybe even a Buick Regal GS.
stovt001 says:
12:24 PM, 02/15/12
Charger Charger Charger Charger Charger Charger. It is a no-brainer - redesigned affordable V8 RWD sedan
texases says:
12:25 PM, 02/15/12
GS350. Not the Evoq, it's too much of a fashion statement.
rl5 says:
12:25 PM, 02/15/12
Used CTS-V would be cool.
2013 MKS with the engine, design and suspension upgrades would be nice as well. No one else would have one.
texases says:
12:26 PM, 02/15/12
And yes, I meant 'Evoque'
ninjatuna says:
12:26 PM, 02/15/12
Once Jaguar comes out with a new model, get that. Though it may be awhile.
csubowtie says:
12:27 PM, 02/15/12
Of the ones mentioned, I would prefer the Malibu the most, it seems more relevant. An iQ would be interesting, and of course one of the Toyobaru twins. An ATS is a must have I think, while a 3 series seems like it will be old hat from the get go. BMW's get soo much press I doubt you guys will say anything we won't have heard a million times already. I would like to see some kind of truck, preferably a small one, but I'm not sure there is anything new out there. Have you guys ever done a Transit Connect? That could be cool, you could even get one with that tool system and tag it to photo equipment or something. And I'm still waiting on that Grand National.
robert4380 says:
12:28 PM, 02/15/12
LAMBORGHINI AVENTADOR!
stovt001 says:
12:29 PM, 02/15/12
Oh yes and a Scion FRS/Subaru BRZ as well. And test the car-seat friendliness of the back seat. It would be nice if I could have a near-Miata once fatherhood arrives.
zoomzoom22 says:
12:29 PM, 02/15/12
I like the GS350 idea. The Evoque is cool but reading about it would be boring...it is more of a fashion accessory than a real car.
I'd like to see a Jaguar in the fleet! Oh, and no more BMW's, please!!!
elgac says:
12:31 PM, 02/15/12
I would love to see something like a 91-95 MR2 to go between your Miata and NSX.
Or maybe an Integra Type R to remind everyone how good a FWD car can be.
dwill83 says:
12:32 PM, 02/15/12
I'd like to see the new VW Passat.
hank39 says:
12:33 PM, 02/15/12
Mazda CX-5 or Mazda5 mini-mini van :)
southernutahn says:
12:34 PM, 02/15/12
As some others have already mentioned, a 2012 ford focus with the dual clutch would be great. A car I am actually considering. I’d like to see how living with the dual clutch is and how reliable it turns out to be.
hondapilot2004 says:
12:34 PM, 02/15/12
CTSV Sport Wagon, simple, done, i would love to see blog posts on this beast. No offense all thr idea cars are not that interesting.
rotaryboff says:
12:36 PM, 02/15/12
Gotta have the 328i. It is the benchmark. The turbo 4 deserves a long look. And I'm considering one. :D
zoomzoom22 says:
12:36 PM, 02/15/12
Also, in the future you guys should definitely get an ATS...maybe wait to get the 328 until you can get an ATS as well for some direct comparisons. I'd love to read about which car you guys like better over the course of a year to see if the ATS really is as competent a 3-series competitor as the GM guys are claiming.
I'd only be interested in a new 3-series if there was an ATS there as well. Otherwise I'm getting a little sick of hearing about BMWs....I skipped over every 5-series post from this blog and will likely skip over every X3 post as well.
Other future cars for the LTRT Blog should include the Dart and Mazda CX-5. I'd love to read about the base model CX-5 with the manual transmission.
coxwill says:
12:37 PM, 02/15/12
So pumped for the Jeep SRT8!
It would be interesting if you got a CTS V Wagon to compare it too...
...otherwise, you guys need another wagon! 3 series wagon? Compare it to your X3?
sandlapper2 says:
12:39 PM, 02/15/12
Evoque would be really cool but what about wait and get the new Azera?
boobylortez says:
12:40 PM, 02/15/12
When you order the Grand Cherokee SRT-8, get UConnect Mobile Internet and panoramic sunroof. Then, put on an extra fuel tank, head east and GO TORNADO CHASING!!!
bodyshopboy says:
12:42 PM, 02/15/12
BMW 328i (make sure you order the "flamer" proof option)
Ford Focus titanium
Mercedes E350 bluetech
Ford Fiesta
Ditto on the CTSV Wagon
revn says:
12:46 PM, 02/15/12
Wow. A couple of these new ones I'm really looking forward to.
I'll second a good chunk of what some others have been saying with the Charger and ATS, and some flavor of the 86. Definitely the Dart once it hits, too. Let's throw in a '13 GT500 too, for ridiculousness.
bankerdanny says:
12:47 PM, 02/15/12
Add me to the Evoque list. Not very practical, but an interesting contrast to the Explorer, with which it shares some powertrain components.
My initial reaction to the 328 was no, IL tests way too many BMW's. But on greater reflection, you have the first really significant new engine in a 3 series in years and I would be interested in a lont term opinion on the turbo 4. Especially from a place like IL that has lots and lots of seat time in Audis and other BMW's.
IL really does need to do a long-term Focus, although waiting for an ST is worth while.
Yes to the Dodge. The only affordable V8 powered sedan left, do it.
revn says:
12:47 PM, 02/15/12
Wow. A couple of these new ones I'm really looking forward to.
I'll second a good chunk of what some others have been saying with the Charger and ATS, and some flavor of the 86. Definitely the Dart once it hits, too. Let's throw in a '13 GT500 too, for ridiculousness.
duck87 says:
12:49 PM, 02/15/12
Get a Dodge Charger as well.
hondapilot2004 says:
12:52 PM, 02/15/12
I agree with the Dodge Charger and Dart, compare them to a Focus, and then the new Fusion when it hits. Also for sheer who gives a damn fun, get the 13' GT500 coupe and a ZL1 convertible since you already had the coupe SS, actually any ZL1 would be great. Oh and an XTS/ATS combo is a must.
chirsch3 says:
12:57 PM, 02/15/12
BMW 328i sport line
boobylortez says:
12:58 PM, 02/15/12
V8 Charger would be cool and all, but the new 8-speed option with the V6 is kind of a big deal. 292 hp, 31 mpg hwy. Just a thought.
stanleypiston says:
01:01 PM, 02/15/12
Scion fr-s or subie next plz
mercedesfan says:
01:02 PM, 02/15/12
I would be really excited to read about the GS350. I was checking one out at a recent auto show and was amazed at the strides that Lexus has made with it. I'm not a fan of the way it looks, but if it drives as well as its interior is built it could be a real winner.
I also would be really interested in reading about the face-lifted MB C-Class. You guys had that C300 a few years back and I would like to see your opinions on the dramatically improved 2012 model. I had one for a loaner last week when my car was in for service and was absolutely blown away by how much it has improved.
Lastly, contrary to what many on here are wishing for I hope you do NOT get a Jaguar. They are achingly beautiful cars and great to drive, but I know 4 people who have had modern Jags (2 XFs, 1 XJ, and 1 XK) and all were nightmares. One of the XFs actually had a slight engine fire due to improper wiring. It is better to admire Jaguars from a distance. ;)
chirsch3 says:
01:04 PM, 02/15/12
Order the top of the line subaru brz as soon as possible auto or manual whichever you can get first
camz7 says:
01:06 PM, 02/15/12
Maybe an iQ, Passat, Prius V, A6, 300 (V6 8 speed auto), 328i
esoterica says:
01:07 PM, 02/15/12
Malibu, so you can compare it to the next Fusion. BMW will give you a 328i eventually anyway.
afty says:
01:07 PM, 02/15/12
I would like to hear about the 328i and the GS350. The 328 is a big deal -- first 3-Series redesign since 2007, a new engine that supposedly exceeds the performance of the NA inline 6 and the fuel economy of the diesel 335d. All the initial reviews have been positive, but nothing gives you a better understanding of a car than living with it for a whole year. The GS350 has been pitched as a new direction for Lexus and has also had very strong initial reviews. You recently had a 528i in your fleet, so it'd be interesting to compare the two.
gslippy says:
01:10 PM, 02/15/12
2012 Hyundai Elantra - I can't believe you haven't had one long-term. Why get more low-volume sellers? I want to know what this car is like to live with.
2013 Dodge Dart (when available) - Chrysler's Hail Mary pass in the compact car market.
rr811 says:
01:19 PM, 02/15/12
Focus ST (When it comes out) or I would like to see a G37 coupe (6MT)
kindofblue says:
01:20 PM, 02/15/12
oh my gosh--Scion iQ. Just to see what it's like to live with one.
Evoque is an obvious yes.
Would also be interested in 328i.
Chrysler 300?
smilez says:
01:21 PM, 02/15/12
F-150 EcoBoost. Supercrew, FX4.
goaterguy says:
01:24 PM, 02/15/12
Jaguar XF (it would be awesome if you guys could get a diesel like the one that crossed the US)
Don't get the XFR or any super iteration of the model, just the base or portfolio.
That would be my next car.
Jaguars are misunderstood and plagued by a bad reputation, it would be cool to prove the public wrong!
offset_98 says:
01:30 PM, 02/15/12
Mercedes C280 4-cyl sedan with automatic.
igeekone says:
01:30 PM, 02/15/12
Lexus GS350 F Sport please. It has high initial reviews and it should be great to see that this not another boring Lexus.
Scion FR-S or the Subaru equivalent because this an interesting new player in the affordable RWD sports car segment
Outside of Toyota, I'd like to see the the Dodge Charger, preferably SRT8, as well as the new Dart. The Dart has the all lcd gauges and Italian underpinnings so that should be an interesting test.
tall10512 says:
01:36 PM, 02/15/12
I would agree with the Evoque and also suggest a Chrysler 300 v6 Limited and a Ford Focus with the much loved/hated auto.
britanniarulz says:
01:38 PM, 02/15/12
The Scion FR-S!! One of the first 86 should surely be available soon...
You have had the BMW 135 in your long term. And your short review of the 128i was a positive influence in my eventually buying my 128i...
I would really like to know if the FR-S is more fun... than the 128i, for instance...
s2k1 says:
01:42 PM, 02/15/12
Out of the choices, 1. Evoque 2. Lexus GS. But I will add my votes for the Jaguar XF and Dodge Charger/300.
goober88 says:
01:46 PM, 02/15/12
I like the 328i out of them all. I would like to see another truck in everything, maybe an F250 King Ranch or a Super Crew Raptor; IL really misses a Raptor...
half_ton says:
01:48 PM, 02/15/12
Ford F150 Ecoboost (which name is worse Ecoboost or Skyactive?). I LOVE the fact that you're getting a JGC SRT8 but my interest lies with a V6 Limited model which I plan to make my next truck purchase. The ATS is a DEFINITE must and that's about it for me.
aspade says:
01:49 PM, 02/15/12
That whole list outside of the SRT8 is one big meh to me.
Loving the LT Wrangler posts. Build up a 10 year old Land Cruiser, stripper new 4Runner, new Tacoma, or F150 XL (with the turbo!) the same way.
On the practical side you guys haven't had a mainstream Chrysler since the 2009 Ram. A V6 Durango or Charger/300 would make interesting comparisons.
neillio says:
01:51 PM, 02/15/12
Jaguar XJ for me. I am definitely curious how the reliable these new Jags are.
_feloniousmonk says:
01:55 PM, 02/15/12
agnh says:
"Ford Focus SE sport pkg 5spd as soon as they have the upcoming Mytouch upgrade."
This, but without MyFordHeadache, please. Just an SE, 5-speed, with sport package. Ford should be applauded for trying to provide some affordable fun at a reasonable price. I'd also like to see an ST, but you need more base to near-base models on here anyway.
Also, down the road:
-a Scion FR-S (cause it's about damn time someone besides Mazda built a real-ass sports car)
-a mid-level new Fusion (who wouldn't be interested in this?)
-a Lotus Evora (or an Elise)
-a base model Toyota Tacoma regular cab, 5-speed 4x4 (someone needs to take a good, long look at one of the last remaining four cylinder, manual transmission 4x4 pickups available for around 20K...plus, it'll be good for hauling stuff)
-a 1970-something Triumph Spitfire/MG/Alfa Spider as a money-pit project car.
alpha01 says:
01:57 PM, 02/15/12
I definitely would like to see the new GS in the fleet, but not the F-Sport. I'd rather see one that appeals more to the masses. One equipped similarly to the C/D test model, just not in Frigidaire white, please.
Also vote for the Dodge Charger - but the V6/8AT, not the V8, and the Ford Focus of any variety, and the upcoming Hyundai Elantra GT. BRZ/FR-S.. can you do both?!!?
_feloniousmonk says:
02:01 PM, 02/15/12
Well, I missed the lists for the upcoming and possible testers...boring and same ol', same ol'. I can see I'll be wasting much less time here in the future.
mmmodem says:
02:03 PM, 02/15/12
It's gotta be the 328. Look at all the comments. It's the m
mmmodem says:
02:12 PM, 02/15/12
It's gotta be the 328. It's the most talked about vehicles in the comments. Alright fine, it's half loathe and half love. There are two reasons it must be in your fleet. One, already mentioned, the turbo 4 is a significant change in the BMW engine lineup worthy of a closer look. Second reason is, it gets 36 mpg? No freaking way this car gets the same hwy fuel economy as my lowly 2006 civic. And if it does, you'll find one in my driveway in the near future. I have a 100+ mile commute. I would love to spend that time in a sporty and fuel efficient automobile.
teampenske3 says:
02:14 PM, 02/15/12
BUY:
Chrysler 300C/Dodge Charger
Range Rover Evoque
Jaguar XF
Toyobaru/Subieyota when it hits dealers
DON'T BUY:
BMW 328i (BMW will probably get you a loaner soon enough anyway)
Ford Focus (wait for the ST please and thank you)
hondacura4 says:
02:14 PM, 02/15/12
My picks:
-Acura ILX 2.4/6MT
-Hyundai Azera
-Hyundai Veloster Turbo
-Chrysler 300/Dodge Charger 3.6
-Dodge Dart
-Lexus GS350 F-Sport
-Mercedes M-Klasse
brent33 says:
02:21 PM, 02/15/12
Evoque, hands down. Lexus and BMW are tired. Do something all new and exciting.
subarubiker says:
02:28 PM, 02/15/12
Since you just lost two semi-crossovers (Juke and Countryman) and will soon lose the Mitsu, I would love to see an Audi Q5 2.0T Premium Plus or, since you haven't had a Subaru since the last WRX STI, how about the best-selling Outback?
Small cars I'd vote for the Ford Focus or a Hyundai Veloster.
jbaker21 says:
02:30 PM, 02/15/12
Get these
Jaguar XJ- give the A8 competition
Jaguar XF- variety
Land Rover LR4- Need a suv
Land Rover Range Rover Sport-
Land Rover Range Rover Evoque- New to the market.
Land Rover Range Rover- Need a luxury off-roader.
ed124c says:
02:31 PM, 02/15/12
Do a "first drive" of the Malibu with the old engine, then wait a few months and get a LT one with the new engine(s).
yesindeed says:
02:34 PM, 02/15/12
I would love to hear about the Mazda CX-5. If you can, I would consider waiting for one or two of the following: Abarth 500, Focus ST, the new Ford Fusion, Dodge Dart, FRS/BRZ - and I do really like the idea of hearing about daily life with an IQ.
mentally says:
02:39 PM, 02/15/12
The new Porsche 911 Carrera S.
mrmistah says:
02:42 PM, 02/15/12
As others have commented the Toyobaruion BR-FT-Z86. Would love to know if it remains being fun behind the wheel after getting over its looks.
cruiserhead1 says:
02:56 PM, 02/15/12
The Kia Cee'd looks like it could be a real player in the econo market.
Hyundai Azera because I want to know what a $30K Azera does that a Genesis sedan doesn't.
The ZR1, because I want to see how long a skid patch you can make with 335's
Prius C, because it's expanding the iconic brand-does it make sense over a petrol econo?
GT86, because it's a possible cult car
911, redesigned and curious
Mazda CX5, worthy against hot competition?
F150 Ecoboost, is it all it promises in the long term?
Hondas suck and Acuras are so boring, you need to boycott them until they get their act together.
isend2c says:
02:56 PM, 02/15/12
The 328i is going to be an important car from BMW, it's their best selling car and the driver favorite (335 and M3 not withstanding). It's rated for 36 MPG highway which is pretty incredible considering it's performance. It's the new car of 2012 I'm most interested in. But don't load it up - keep the options to a minimum, like the E90 330i you had.
I'd also like to see the FR-S / BRZ and an iQ. The iQ is a design miracle and I'm so interested in it just because of that, it seems like all the car anyone should ever need, NEED I said, not want!
bonzjr says:
02:59 PM, 02/15/12
Of cars you can buy today:
(1) Focus SE 5-door with a stick, sport package, 203A equipment group and moonroof. Why? To show Mazda how it SHOULD be done! This is a selfish request on my part. Since Mazda refuses to ever build Skyactiv anything with a stick and any desirable options the Focus has moved into frontrunner position as 'my next car' thus ending my long streak of only Mazda ownership. After buying three in well over a decade of loyalty, it's time for me to move on and I'd love to see how a Focus holds up. Seriously, though, it would give a lot of your readership who keep clamoring for manual trans reviews in practical applications (keep reading the Mazda3 threads, the Straightline new car intro threads, etc.) something to chew on for a year. Also, let's face it, after having a Cruze now you need a Focus to see how it stacks up.
Beyond that...
(2) I would actually love to see a Charger in the fleet. Can a big, everyday RWD American car be relevant in the modern world? (I like to think it can...) Any engine would do. The V6 is the most practical, but people will whine if you don't get the V8.
(3) Lexus GS350 (any variety, but F-Sport would be nice). Did Lexus catch the Germans? Initial reviews say so... live with one for a year and tell us!
(4) Hyundai Elantra. Does nothing for me personally, but why not? They sell billions of them so let's see how it does. If you made it the "GT" version however... I would suddenly be interested (especially manual, sport pack, roof... see my Focus request).
Of stuff you can get soon, but not yet...
** 2013 Ford Fusion
** 2013 Dodge Dart
** 2013 Chevrolet Malibu (without the Eco pack! -- see below)
** 2013 Cadillac ATS (turbo variant, stick shift only just because you can!)
Things I don't want to see:
(1) For the love of God please stay away from the BMWs for a while. Yes it's a new 3-series. So what? You've had seven BMWs already (per the list @ right) and though they're a top selling luxury brand, compared to the rest of the market this is WAY out of proportion from a percentage standpoint. Just lay off it. For like... six months. Maybe a year. Can you do that please?
(2) Chevy Malibu Eco. No one is going to buy it. The regular Malibu is where it's at. And it has an all-new engine which should be tested too (as opposed to the Eco which is a rehash of the current 2.4/super-alternator combo). It'll be cheaper, drive better, be more practical, and probably match the mileage of the Eco version anyway (if it's like GM's recent version of that 'technology' -- and let's face it, it is).
saunupe1911 says:
03:01 PM, 02/15/12
Jeep Grand Cherokee SRT8 or 328i
00s10 says:
03:12 PM, 02/15/12
Why not get a SAAB. Test it to see if it was worth the BMW price. Or get an older used one that still had all the quirkiness that made a SAAB a SAAB.
ahightower says:
03:35 PM, 02/15/12
911
Lexus CTh
V6 300 or Charger
Elantra wagon
christople says:
03:39 PM, 02/15/12
I think you should get the S2000 or used boxster to take place of the miata.
Lexus ES because of how major the upgrades have been.
Range if you need the suv
mentally says:
03:49 PM, 02/15/12
The new Mercedes-Benz M-Class.
yellowperil says:
03:52 PM, 02/15/12
It's too bad you've recently tested the Optima & Sonata. I'd like to see how the Korean Hybrids perform over the long term.
Would also like to see the CX-5!
rjohnstonstl says:
03:53 PM, 02/15/12
A vote for the Audi A6 here, but order one with the 2.0T. We already know the 3.0T is a phenomenal engine and works well in the A6, but very few, if any, real-world driving impressions of the A6 with the smaller, more economical engine have been published. Testing an A6 2.0T for a year would also be helpful in that you could judge it against the smaller engined 5-series Bimmer you had for a year.
kingkhalas says:
03:56 PM, 02/15/12
1. Any Tesla when they become available
2. Kia Soul
3. Hyunda Elantra GT
4. Hyundai Velociter
5. mini cooper s roadster
6.subaru brz
acbayard says:
04:11 PM, 02/15/12
Scion iQ - to compare with the Fiat 500.
cdp8 says:
04:23 PM, 02/15/12
Please say "no" to the Evoque. Who needs a utility vehicle where the back seat and cargo area are so severely restricted in a lame attempt to look cool? It's an SUV; it's supposed to be a box.
Please put a 2013 Ford Fusion (not hybrid) in your line up as soon as they are available.
Wish your JGC was not the SRT8.
Cadillac CTS Wagon
How about another classic, like an early 70's Alfa Romeo GTV? Here is one in L.A. for $14K:
http://www.alfabb.com/bb/forums/alfa-romeo-cars-sale-wanted/190816-1974-gtv-2000-a.html
socalaj1 says:
04:35 PM, 02/15/12
How about a Nissan Versa with absolutely no options? What is it like to drive the cheapest new car in America?
How about a comparison of pre-owned performance vehicles (M5, E55 AMG, Audi RS6, Jag XJR) get them all at once and compare what its like to get a last or two gen ago performance sedan vs a new base model.
A Focus titanium would be good. Does the self parking work, is it a fun drive, is sync mytouch getting any better?
Mini Roadster JCW, is it worth the money over a Miata or more fun than a TT?
A Motorcycle. Might be interesting to see a review on something a little different.
lautomobile says:
04:51 PM, 02/15/12
1. 2013 BRZ / FR-S
2. 2013 Focus ST
3. 2012 Fiesta
4. 2013 Elantra GT (Hatch)
carfreak13 says:
04:53 PM, 02/15/12
RANG ROVER EVOQUE
JAGUAR XF (or any jag)
FORD FUSION ENERGi
brendan_m says:
04:57 PM, 02/15/12
+1 to the CX-5 idea. And Ford Escape.
+1 to the Subaru BRZ or Scion FR-S.
Heck, maybe even wait for the Buick Encore? I know the Cruze departed recently and you've got the Sonic in the lineup, so maybe another GM 1.4 turbo would be redundant, but I'd be morbidly curious to see how the little lump performs... in day-to-day life.
wheelmccoy says:
05:11 PM, 02/15/12
@brendan_m - we have similar interests.
+1 for Mazda CX-5
+1 for Suburu BRZ or Scion FR-S
Add Acura ILX.
evodad says:
05:13 PM, 02/15/12
I know you've done a CTS, but I'd love to see a CTS-V wagon, who wouldn't love to read about that?
brokenaudi says:
05:16 PM, 02/15/12
sounds like a good mix of cars you've already ordered.
PLEASE save room for a BRZ/FR-S. The evoque would be interesting, and so would the gs350. But please, please no 328i. We are all sick of bimmers.
mazeroni says:
05:20 PM, 02/15/12
Subaru BRZ or Scion FRS
2013 Gen Coupe 2.0t or 3.8
Mazda CX-5
church123 says:
05:21 PM, 02/15/12
Wow, sounds like a big rolling pile of boring suckage on the way in (of course, I'll exclude the Jeep SRT8 from that categorization).
In light of this, I recommend some vehicles that have largely already been mentioned to balance out the boring, slow, impracticalness of the incoming fleet.
1. Ford Ecoboost F150 (or, alternatively, a heavy duty diesel equipped truck - you had 3 minivans in the fleet at once, a couple trucks wouldn't hurt at the same time, especially if they're competitors).
2. Porsche Cayman S/R - let's experience the most affordable and perhaps sweetest handling car that Porsche makes. What's it like to live with in LA?
3. Caddy CTS-V, wagon preferably - Can't believe you guys have never had one of these.
4. Mercedes Benz E350 - you guys have done so few Benzs that I'd really like to see how a mid-level Mercedes does over the course of a year.
5. Audi TT roadster. You need more convertibles, and while I'm not an Audi fan, this one is so different from the rest of the entry lux roadsters that I think it would be a worthwhile car to evaluate.
6. Nissan NV2500 van. C'mon, get a big 'ol industrial vehicle and see what its like, even if its only for a 3 month eval. Alternatively you could do a Dodge Sprinter. Your photogs will never have to worry about space for their gear again.
7. Acura RDX if you can get one. The CRV revamp is pretty solid, but its a boring class of vehicle. That chassis with better AWD and a V6 might be pretty cool.
exnevadan says:
05:22 PM, 02/15/12
CTS-V sedan or wagon (six speed manual) or Jaguar XF (preferably R or supercharged)
Malibu sedan (biggest motor available) or Fusion sedan (biggest motor available)
Lexus GS350 (F Sport would be a plus)
Porsche Carrera (preferably S w/ seven speed manual)
firelicked says:
05:41 PM, 02/15/12
Honda CR-Z, Mazda CX-5 and Toyota Tacoma. And throw in a 93 Mazda RX-7 or better to compare to the NSX. Get ride of the craptacular Porsche. Also, a nice swan song to the RX-8 would be a good read too.
tenstepn says:
05:53 PM, 02/15/12
My vote is for something used...another project car! Something real people can afford to buy or add to their own fleet! I never liked or considered a Miata until I started following Project Miata! And the NSX! Great stuff!
allenr13 says:
06:02 PM, 02/15/12
I would agree with the 2012 Focus with powershift (not the ST, most of us will never afford one) and the 2013 Fusion. I'm looking at either as pre-owned purchases for the future.
blueprint1 says:
06:04 PM, 02/15/12
Land Rover Evoque (not as good as a used Mulsanne, but still British).
Ford Focus with the Powershift - not what I'd buy, but that tranny seems horrible in reviews.
Dodge Dart.
Ford Fusion 2013, with Ecoboost.
Ford Escape, ditto.
Mazda CX-5 fwd manual.
The only 328i you're allowed to get is a CPO car at least 3 years old, with a stick but without the sport pkg.
Buick Verano.
Kia Soul 4U manual (seems pretty good for the price).
Dodge Charger with the V-6 and 8-speed slushbox.
Malibu not a bad choice with the Camry in the fleet for comparisons.
Lexus GS350? Boring reads ahead.
threem says:
06:17 PM, 02/15/12
Also would put in a strong vote for the Charger. It's the only reasonably priced RWD sedan on the market (for those of us who can't swing a 5 series, but might have kids some day)- also those of us who grew up watching the Dukes of Hazzard at 8:00, on Friday nights would like to know if driving a Toxic Orange Charger is everything we would hope it would be.
cuselancer17 says:
06:19 PM, 02/15/12
So Excited for the SRT8. The GS would be nice. 1+ to the CX-5 and any Jag. But please, please do the Evoque.PLEASE!. I will literally wait by the computer for each post....AND NO 328I.
blueprint1 says:
06:25 PM, 02/15/12
Forgot these three:
Either a Scion FR-S or a Subie BRZ;
Acura ILX 2.4 manual;
SAAB 9-5 (interesting to see what CarMax will offer at the end of the test...).
mikerobb says:
06:26 PM, 02/15/12
I would like to see the 2012 VW Passat with the real 6 speed MANUAL transmission(remember, the ones with a clutch pedal). I think the mpg figures will blow the hybrids out of the water. No need to sue anyone for false numbers, you will beat the EPA numbers easily.
pakjk says:
06:29 PM, 02/15/12
Get a BRZ (MT) and a Veloster Turbo (MT)
Comparing the two long term would be great.
samster231 says:
06:30 PM, 02/15/12
"In the future ATS and Dart are no brainers."
Agreed.
I would also add new Fusion to that list.
pontiaksolsice says:
06:40 PM, 02/15/12
Another vote for a Charger/300 with a V6 and 8 Speed.
The VW Passat would be interesting considering it is somewhat different than any Passat before it.
The 328i should definitely be done, but I'm not sure that right now is the time to do it, I would rather see that and the ATS as Long Term Cars at the same time for a better comparison.
Maybe a Buick, I'm undecided as to which one though. I don't think a Regal GS is the best choice, I love it but I think something like the Verano or a LaCrosse eAssist would be a more appropriate choice. Of course, if you do a Malibu Eco, there is really no point in an LaCrosse eAssist..is there?
The new Porsche 911 should be done at some point, it would be great to have the old and new together.
And lastly, I think the Subie BRZ would be a great addition.
geneseedepot says:
06:43 PM, 02/15/12
VW CC, Turbo Beetle, Passat
328i
'12 Impreza CVT
Focus Titanium (manual)
Veloster
billt9 says:
06:50 PM, 02/15/12
GS-F! Lexus' first real car!
musclecarfancy says:
06:52 PM, 02/15/12
perhaps a CTS with the LFX, a FR-S or the 328i
and seeing the mustang should be leaving soon.....a ZL1 couldnt hurt ;)
revbob says:
06:54 PM, 02/15/12
Not a fan of the basic 4 door sedan. Love wagons, hatches, crossovers, anything somewhat unique - but keep it on the cheap side (with m/t if possible). So:
Mazda cx-5
Scion/Subaru
Kia Soul
revbob says:
06:56 PM, 02/15/12
Not a fan of the basic 4 door sedan. Love wagons, hatches, crossovers, anything somewhat unique - but keep it on the cheap side (with m/t if possible). So:
Mazda cx-5
Scion/Subaru
Kia Soul
epbrown says:
07:07 PM, 02/15/12
Typically the rationale given for Edmunds to buy a car is a new model, new brand, or a significant new technology - it's why you guys ran a Smart Fortwo and a Fiat 500 when they were introduced to the US, the electric Mini E and sundry hybrids. That makes sense, as living with them is different than reviewing them.
Jaguar has been through some drastic changes lately, practically re-inventing the brand, and Edmunds hasn't tried either the XF or XJ long-term. That's amazing, considering the number of BMWs listed in the present and long-term tests that are pretty much updates of long-time models. Rather than another 3-series (which should be darn close to your 5-series and X3 in a lot of ways, as Carroll Lachnit pointed out recently), how about a Jaguar XF?
And before I'm lumped in with the BMW haters - I'm a paid-up member of the BMWCCA, and I've bought 5 BMWs in the last years. I just think you guys have covered the brand quite well, along with Audi. There's little coverage of Mercedes-Benz and I see the lack of Jaguar coverage as a huge gap in the premium car segment.
veritas5a says:
07:14 PM, 02/15/12
One of the Scion FRS/Subaru BRZ twins would be nice.
myleftfoot says:
07:44 PM, 02/15/12
Focus titanium 6 speed
Fiat 500 abarth
Malibu eco
mikerobb says:
07:47 PM, 02/15/12
Sorry, just to be clear, I meant to say the VW Passat DIESEL with manual tranny.
dubyatx says:
08:13 PM, 02/15/12
The cars on the list would all be great additions, but if I got to choose, I would like to see at least one (or more!) of the following cars:
1. Mazda CX-5, because I want to see how the SkyActiv concept holds up in a utility vehicle.
2. Prius C, to see if its fuel economy claims hold up and if the higher price would be worth it for a compact vehicle in the long run. The combination of size and hybrid seem promising, I would like to know if this is going to be *the* new small car to get.
3. Volkswagen Passat, because I want to see how it holds up against the Camry/Sonata/Optima etc.
4. Audi A6 2.0T, I want to see how this small engine works in a car this large
5. Chrysler Town & Country/Dodge Caravan: you've tested all other important minivans so far, might as well do the last one too and see how it stacks up over time (and if it does any better than the previous iterations).
And as a project car: an old Saab 900 Classic…lots to be modded on these to make them go faster, and definitely the most (last?) iconic car from the brand--at least in recent history.
canddmeyer says:
08:27 PM, 02/15/12
Not thrilled at all with the future SRT8. I'd be happier to see any of the other 10 or so Grand Cherokee 4x2 or 4x4 models with the V6 or Hemi, but not the SRT8.
As for a future pick, the BMW 328i is where I'd like to see the money spent. The Evoque, Malibu, and Lexus don't strike me as best bang for the buck.
canddmeyer says:
08:37 PM, 02/15/12
And the better idea? The Dodge Charger V6.
bassrockerx says:
08:45 PM, 02/15/12
AUDI ALLROAD!
stanleypiston says:
09:43 PM, 02/15/12
FR-S or BRZ plz... affordable daily sport car!
djefferson says:
09:50 PM, 02/15/12
FR-S and BR-Z.....we are all waiting for this comparison test...enough said,
Dodge Charger RT/SXT track testing of both: Hemi long term, though SXT 8sp should be 1st choice,
Ford Focus Titanium 18inch sport pkg track test both new 5sp manual and auto, manual long term,
Lexus GS 350 F-Sport,
Rover Evogue 2dr,
BMW 328i/335i track test and compare all variations in transmission with sport package and keep the 8sp auto 328i for the long term with 240hp at the wheels it should be fun.
mhauer says:
10:07 PM, 02/15/12
I'm with Church123 on the trucks.
I've noticed that IL is seriously lacking in the truck department. So, here's what I'm thinking... I know you recently had a Ford F 150 Raptor, which is the total "toy" end of the truck spectrum... Now I'm thinking you really, really, really owe it to all of us truck guys to do a Long Term test of an F 150 with the Eco Boost V6. Maybe in Lariat trim - Crew Cab configuration. Just make sure you beat the hell out of it. I'm very curious to see how those turbos hold up over a year or more.
... Or you could get a GMC Sierra 2500 Denali with the DuraMax. I'd love to see what it's like living with a 3/4 ton diesel pick up in Santa Monica and the surrounding areas.
sdtundra858 says:
10:16 PM, 02/15/12
Prius c 4. 23800 with nav and all the goodies or 18500 for a base model and 53/48mpg while still being cheaper and bigger than the comparable Honda's.
salo3 says:
10:26 PM, 02/15/12
CHARGER OR 300, NO QUESTION!!!
bassrockerx says:
11:40 PM, 02/15/12
i agree nissan versa with no options! also i know you have two jeeps now but im interested in the jeep patriot with no options but 4x4 would be awesome to test the cheapest car in america side by side against the cheapest suv in america. also im interested in the 2012 subaru impreza sedan i want to see if it can really get 36mpg becasue 36mpg with awd is a really big deal!
remdog says:
12:20 AM, 02/16/12
How about a new Saab 9-5? Or maybe an old 9000 aero, to show the Panamera how a sports hatch is really done.
varezhka says:
01:04 AM, 02/16/12
Scion iQ, FR-S, Toyota Prius C, and Dodge Dart would by my choices.
Of those listed, the Lexus GS sounds the most interesting, but none of them are particularly compelling. Just no more BMW, please!
miraa says:
01:09 AM, 02/16/12
You have to go 328i due to the massive change from the much adored inline six to the 2.0 turbo 4. We need to know if it holds up. Also, a BRZ or FR-S must be on th docket. Hey, why not check out a Mazda 5 to examine how it stacks up against the recent minivan onslaught?
litewerk says:
01:14 AM, 02/16/12
Scion iQ
Elantra
Focus (esp. the ST)
Verano
Charger
Azera
CX-5
Passat (w/manual)
When available, the Dart, ATS, Fusion and Malibu. And one of the Toyobaru twins.
And, personally, no interest in the Evoque.
ghiafan says:
04:38 AM, 02/16/12
Peugeot 508
Ford CMax/Grand C-Max 1.6L EcoBoost 180hp 6spd manual
Citroën C4
Ford Mondeo 2.0L 240hp EcoBoost
Alfa Romeo Giulietta 1.4 litre Multiair/168bhp
oops wrong continent
You testers must get bored over there
eclogite says:
04:48 AM, 02/16/12
Mazda CX-5
Subaru Outback 3.5 (I know, you've already got an Impreza on order, but you asked my opinion...)
Ford C-Max Hybrid
Toyota Venza
gxp_mike says:
04:59 AM, 02/16/12
Please, consider a Dodge Charger R/T!!!!
mr_tim says:
05:40 AM, 02/16/12
I'd like to see an Ecoboost F150 in either Lariat or FX4 trim or a 2012 Toyota Tacoma TRD Off Road.
revs29 says:
06:49 AM, 02/16/12
New cars:
Dodge Durango
Dodge Dart
Jaguar XJ
Scion iQ (to punish you for getting that boring X3)
Veloster Turbo
Honda CR-Z
Acura RDX
Acura TL SH-AWD 6MT
Porsche Cayman R
Lexus GS350
Used Cars:
AP1 S2000 (2000-2003) - I think this is a MUST for you guys. Project Miata x10
Lotus Elise
E39 BMW M5
CTS-V
GTO
996 911
hondapilot2004 says:
07:34 AM, 02/16/12
I second revs.. E39 M5 is a MUST for a used car, do us all justice (and yourselves) after that sad sack 911 that no one needed to read about or drive..
06scooby says:
07:36 AM, 02/16/12
wow... so many comments already!
I like a lot of the lists. I agree that a new focus needs to be in the mix and the new Elantra GT needs to be in the mix. If not the elantra I think a Kia Rio or Accent needs to be in your fleet.
I am excited to see the impreza coming. We are in the market for a smaller 4 door car (since my 14 year old truck finally kicked the bucket) and I really like the new impreza's on paper. Haven't gotten around to driving one yet but for the price they give the typical "compact" cars a run for their money with offering AWD at the same price. I'm starting to see them pop up all over up here around Lake Tahoe. Get a hatch back 2.0i premium model with the CVT and with or without the sunroof as that seems to be the volume seller. And get the inexpensive All-weather package so Donna can have them heated seats! :-)
blueguydotcom says:
07:38 AM, 02/16/12
Lexus or Chevy.
Please not another damned BMW.
thehankhill says:
07:44 AM, 02/16/12
Another vote for the stripped Versa. The editors will whine and it may be hard to get 20k on the clock, but it would be interesting to have one in the fleet. Find out what the cheapest new car in America is really like to own and drive on a daily basis.
hondapilot2004 says:
08:02 AM, 02/16/12
@blueguy:
I too am against the new 3 Series, but come on the E39 M5 is simply beyond all not another BMW type deal.. Id want to read about only that BMW (or an X5/X6M) other than that not interested.
DLu says:
08:13 AM, 02/16/12
New:
XF (or XJ)
Used:
RX-8
CTS-V (wagon)
wsmithson says:
08:19 AM, 02/16/12
Consider a E39 5 series, I'm really quite interested.. or a E34 M5, that'd be a brilliant test. But If you must have a new car, I'd say the 2 door Evouge in white or that steel blue colour with all the options and extra's. No X3, X5, or X6's.. please, we don't care about those cars. It's not particular beautiful, it's not particularly useful. It was built by a world, for a world, that doesn't really exist anymore. Remind you of anything? To sum up then, the Range Rover is a much better all rounder.
e90_m3 says:
08:19 AM, 02/16/12
Jag or Land Rover. I want to see if they still deserve their reputation on reliability... or the lack thereof.
brogan2 says:
08:30 AM, 02/16/12
Touareg TDI Lux: Perfect to show the capabilities of a diesel (+ 8Speed auto) in americans favorite vehicles, SUVs.
4runner: still an old school SUV, capability to seat 7 and hit a trail.
Agree with others mentioned above: Focus ST, FR-S/BRZ, Evoque, CX-5, and 328
brogan2 says:
08:31 AM, 02/16/12
Touareg TDI Lux: Perfect to show the capabilities of a diesel (+ 8Speed auto) in americans favorite vehicles, SUVs.
4runner: still an old school SUV, capability to seat 7 and hit a trail.
Agree with others mentioned above: Focus ST, FR-S/BRZ, Evoque, CX-5, and 328
thegraduate says:
08:37 AM, 02/16/12
Ford Focus WITH PowerShift - test what most of the commuting world will buy anyway
Malibu
And, ditto on saving for the Dart, CX-5, and Fusion.
tshoe says:
08:47 AM, 02/16/12
I like the idea of the 328i and the LR Evoque.
Also vote for:
Acura ILX and RDX
VW Touareg
Mercedes ML (anytype)
pete5o5 says:
08:55 AM, 02/16/12
I say go cheap, get a Kia Rio5 or Toyota Yaris SE.
cr_driver says:
09:08 AM, 02/16/12
OK, if you guys get the Lexus GS and the Land Rover Evoque, you will be up to date and also finally mixing it up, when it comes to the brands of cars you have here, plus finally listening to your bloggers.
Now, get a Jaguar XF and this could become almost perfect.
You guys can do it, don`t screw it up.
yellowmiata says:
09:19 AM, 02/16/12
WAIT!!!
Lets expand ILs viewer base. What about a motorcycle?
Lets start with a gentleman's litre bike: the Yamaha FZ1 or Ducati Monster or Triumph Speed Triple? The price is WAY low and it'd be great to do some bike/car comparos just for grins. Besides you'd get a whole 'nother reader base here...
Maybe I should do a full writeup of my bike and send it in for fodder...
Kevin
dougnash2009 says:
09:23 AM, 02/16/12
What should you buy next? Easy. Buy my car from me, and I'LL test the Jeep SRT8 for the next five-years.
hybris says:
10:05 AM, 02/16/12
Get a basic working mans pickup XL or XLT trim for Ford or WT for Chevy or ST for Dodge (Ram) either way just get a truck.
Regular Cab
8 foot bed
Big V8 or a Ecoboost if you want to go down that path again.
I won't say no if you want to stay with your "We need a truck with 4 doors" obsession if it was a 1 ton (or heavier) DIESEL 4x4 LONG BED from really any brand (I am curious about life with the new Powerstroke though).
And of course there is always my earlier suggestion about getting either a used Ford Excursion (V10 or Diesel) or a new 3/4 ton Suburban SUV.
jaguar36 says:
10:10 AM, 02/16/12
328i! Then an Evoque!
jaystar says:
10:13 AM, 02/16/12
My vote would be for the CTS wagon. While the V version would be awesome, the mileage isn't practical.
A 300 would be nice too.
_feloniousmonk says:
11:32 AM, 02/16/12
I can't believe how many of you creeps want to see a Focus with the "POWARSHIFT!!!" Thanks to every review out there, we already know it sucks for anything but basic commuting, and it's sometimes suspect at even that. It's time to throw some light on the fact that Ford still offers a pretty good manual in a decently contented car at a reasonable price: the SE. The Titanium is just another example of a loaded small car at a pricepoint overlapping larger offerings. The ST would be nifty, but I'd rather see what a mainline Focus is like to live with.
Like I already mentioned, you haven't done a small pickup, so grab a base model regular cab, 5-speed, 4x4 Tacoma.
Actually, you could set a price limit for around $20,000.00 and buy the best manual transmission-ed car and 4x4 pickup you can get for that. Both the Focus SE, 5spd, sport package and the aforementioned Taco fit that bill, but it'd be fun to see what else is available in that bracket. I know the only alternative to the Tacoma is the Colorado/Canyon "work truck", but I have no idea what Kia, Toyota, et al offer to compete with the Focus SE manual.
No more BMWs, they ain't what they used to be and I'm personally sick of 'em.
No more SUV/CUVs for a bit, thanks.
I also like the idea of the base Versa. I'd actually like to see you cover more small cars like the Yaris or Rio.
apinault says:
11:55 AM, 02/16/12
It has to be the 328i!!
msmlexis says:
12:03 PM, 02/16/12
I am a Lexus fan through and through. However i really like the new 3. Please buy a 328i in red with a sixspeed manual and black interior so i can know exactly what its like to own. Also tune it i want to see its potential.
blueguydotcom says:
12:11 PM, 02/16/12
@hondapilot - agree the ole e39 M5 is neat but no. They really need to stop shilling for BMW and Audi.
miamifan1 says:
12:17 PM, 02/16/12
Get an Evoque please. Very interested in its reliability/livability.
Wait for an F30 BMW convertible rather than the plebeian sedan. Mix things up a bit with the BMW parade...
angry_mushroom says:
01:03 PM, 02/16/12
Why not look into a last year Saab 9-5? Would be a good example of what to do when an owner is left high and dry. Otherwise I'd go for the Malibu Eco.
toyotapowerx says:
01:23 PM, 02/16/12
FT-86
jlh3 says:
01:30 PM, 02/16/12
I would vote for a jaguar
bthayer23 says:
01:32 PM, 02/16/12
VELOSTER TURBO FTW!
Also, a 991 911 would be nice.
al2travel says:
02:09 PM, 02/16/12
I urge you to choose the Lexus Gs 350 F Sport RWD with handling pkg.
Reason , this car according to LEXUS, is the beginning of a new era of more driver oriented Lexus cars. Lets see how it performs in the real world vs your database of German cars.
candurandu says:
02:16 PM, 02/16/12
Tesla model S
PLUS- loan it to a loyal reader (me) to drive and blog about for the 20,000 mile life of the test.
velocity_x says:
02:28 PM, 02/16/12
Definitely get a top-spec Scion FR-S or Subaru BRZ with the 6-speed manual.
velocity_x says:
03:04 PM, 02/16/12
@ Scott Oldham:
What's the specification of the '12 Impreza that IL is getting ?
madrussian190 says:
03:43 PM, 02/16/12
I vote 2012 Acura TL SH-AWD.
blakebyrns says:
04:13 PM, 02/16/12
i permit you to purchase the lexus F sport or the RR Evoque
zspyyy says:
04:14 PM, 02/16/12
GS 350 F SPORT!!! Please, please, please.
v10powerrrr says:
04:48 PM, 02/16/12
Bugatti Veyron with out a doubt
pezzy669 says:
05:06 PM, 02/16/12
Hyundai Elantra Limited.
Wanna see a comparison between the multiple "40 MPG" cars in the subcompact/compact class. :)
sharvan456 says:
07:23 PM, 02/16/12
I'd like to see how the new mercedes CLS 550 and BMW 550xi perform on a long term and find out they both differ in the way they perform,handle and the driver experience associated with those cars.
hotrodw says:
08:09 PM, 02/16/12
With so much new inventory on the way, I suggest you exercise some patience and hang tight for a bit. There is lots of good stuff just around the corner. May I recommend:
SLK AMG
2013 RDX
2013 A4 Allroad
2013 Escape Titanium or SEL 2.0 EcoBoost
2013 Fusion 2.0 EcoBoost AWD
2013 Genesis Coupe (3.8 or turbo)
If you must get something now:
TT RS
Golf R20
A7
Tiguan SEL
CR-V
Evoque
yaymx5 says:
11:37 PM, 02/16/12
Subaru BRZ / Scion FR-S
I (and probably all the readers) really want to see what it's like to own one. I'm considering replacing my Miata with a Toyobaru. :)
cx7lover says:
12:58 AM, 02/17/12
Evoque
Evoque
Evoque
Evoque
Evoque
Evoque
Evoque
Evoque
CX-5
goldendragon18 says:
03:43 AM, 02/17/12
I think that you should get the Lexus GS350 F. 1. I don't remember you guys ever having a Lexus. 2. I think that since it is always always a popular buy, it would benefit people who are out looking for one to see how it compares up to old Lexuses and the BMW 5 series and Infiniti M that you guys just got rid of. 3. You guys always have a BMW in the fleet, and since BMWs have pretty much the same personality throughout the board no matter of price range, that it wouldn't benefit the blog to have a 3 series. I do agree with people in getting the Evoque and a Jaguar of any kind. They are always understated and should receive some more attention.
aneesh says:
04:07 AM, 02/17/12
The Hyundai Elantra-since it did win the 2012 NACOTY
Veloster Turbo
Mazda CX-5
the ATS when it comes out
cradd858 says:
06:08 AM, 02/17/12
1st choice: Subaru BRZ
2nd choice: Subaru BRZ
3rd choice: Scion FR-S
cyerkes says:
08:28 AM, 02/17/12
These are what I would like to see
--Mazda CX-5
--Range Rover Evoque
cyerkes says:
08:29 AM, 02/17/12
These are what I would like to see:
--Mazda CX-5
--Range Rover Evoque
--Lexus GS350 F Sport
carolinaking says:
09:21 AM, 02/17/12
Lexus GSh
Lexus CTh
Jaguar XJL
Land Rover LR4
ianzoe1 says:
10:35 AM, 02/17/12
I thinkn the new Kia Soul with the new engine and trans.
Besides it's a cool car.....maybe you'll even get the hamsters to come with it!
nolessthenv8 says:
10:45 AM, 02/17/12
I strongly believe that you guys should buy a 2013 Shelby GT500, I Know this will be my next car, please evaluate and do a long term test on it. Make sure to test one with the Performance Pack, i don't think I will hit the track with this car but might as well also add on the Track Pack. I would like to know what you guys think of the glass roof and how it effects driving and the experience in this car since I am almost certain i want my Shelby to include a glass roof. Last but not least I would like to know how the Recaro seats measure up against the regular seats over time. I think they look amazing and I am almost certain I want these seats when I purchase the car but are comfortable enough to live with over time?
your next purchase should without a doubt be a 2013 Shelby GT500
pdbrasil says:
10:55 AM, 02/17/12
I have to throw in my vote for the redesigned Chryslers. Specifically the Charger, 300, and/or Durango. V8 would be sweet, but also interested in impressions of the 3.6 w/ 8 speed. It would be nice to see how the Durango stacks up against the Explorer since so many reviewers have differing opinions on which is better. I'm also sick of all the BMWs...
And of course, Dodge Dart when it's released.
compressor says:
12:12 PM, 02/17/12
a4 allroad
gmax876 says:
11:25 PM, 02/17/12
2012 Acura TL and drive the friggin wheels off, I wanna see track test videos, dyno numbers, the works! I just bought one and HOLY SHIT is it bad ass, I'm talking 115 mph cornering performance. TRUE STORY!!
dclsmit says:
01:51 AM, 02/18/12
How about something that can be used in a B-Spec race?
It would be something economical and cheap to run, but has the potential to be turned into a fun, little race car.
If not, you guys should do another project again. Maybe a rebuild of a car.
shewbiedo says:
05:08 PM, 02/18/12
328i -- although I wish you guys hadn't pegged everyone's hate-meter by accepting the X3 so recently.
And an ATS when available.
bluestrider12 says:
05:54 PM, 02/18/12
Get the Evoque!!
I love the eye catching lines and I'm curious to see if it has everyday practicality. Try and get the 2 door!
joshuma38 says:
03:02 AM, 02/19/12
the new jeep Grand Cherokee!
ynnemesis says:
05:06 AM, 02/19/12
I think you should get 2012 hyundai genesis sedan V6. I know you already tested Hyundai Genesis 5.0 R-Spec, but what about the suspension improvements and performance on the base models?
aviboy97 says:
06:33 AM, 02/19/12
Considering you guys like to purchase cars that 99% of us will never own, I say buy a couple of the new small crossovers for a head-to-head comaro!
I would like to see the CR-V EX-L AWD vs Mazda CX-5 GT AWD vs Ford Escape 1.6L EcoBoost AWD
mozzz77788 says:
10:06 AM, 02/19/12
1. 328i
2. Lexus GS
3. Evoque
Heck get all 3!
cruzcontrol says:
12:11 PM, 02/19/12
STAFF:
PLEASE PURCHASE A NEBULA GRAY LEXUS GS350 F-SPORT W/ THE RED INTERIOR AND BRUSHED ALUMINUM TRIM!!!
rks838 says:
04:21 PM, 02/19/12
FR-S or BRZ!
The return of the affordable sports car...
The idea that less ultimate performance could make for a better car...
(Chris Harris took this idea to the extreme, with good results - a C63 on spare tires - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HPh90yNX-mY. It's about time you guys restarted a weekly, or perhaps monthly, car video recommendation list!)
itsmpt says:
07:43 PM, 02/19/12
As typical consumer, vehicles I would be interested in are:
1) Subaru BRZ or FT-86
2) Subaru Impreza (Hatchback of course)
3) Mazda CX-5
4) BMW 3 series
5) Hyundai Veloster
6) Ford Focus
7) VW Beetle w/ 2.0T Hatchback
8) Scion iQ
9) Ford Taurus SHO (2013)
10) Toyota Prius C
omarccx says:
01:26 PM, 02/20/12
Scion FR-S
2013 Hyundai Genesis Coupe
Jaguar XF
Acura TL SH-AWD
Range Rover Evoque
Hyundai Veloster
Lexus GS F Package
hb22 says:
02:55 PM, 02/20/12
Land Rover Evoque
hotpass105 says:
02:57 PM, 02/20/12
I wanna hear about a new Ford!
2013 Fusion
2012 Focus
brendanao says:
03:15 PM, 02/20/12
I think that you are forgetting about one of the most important releases of the year. The new Ford Fusion. You do not have a mid size sedan on this list and it will be a very important car. Please add it!
gsschro2 says:
03:33 PM, 02/20/12
What about a Prius C or Subaru BRZ?
jettawolf says:
05:03 PM, 02/20/12
To agree with multiple respondents:
Hyundai Veloster
Honda CR-Z
Ford Focus hatch
Subaru BRZ
VW Beetle
And later on, after it is released, Dodge Dart?
illankid says:
05:31 PM, 02/20/12
2012 328i Sound nice
here are my suggestions
94-98 Toyota Supra( depreciation immune?)
2012 elantra (lets see how much frugal this car is)
2012 dodge charger rt or 300c ( 4 door sedan rwd)
2013 Genesis Coupe (more HP means better car?)
subiefanil83 says:
10:01 PM, 02/20/12
I will say the Impreza with the CVT. That way we can know if the claimed fuel economy is as good as they say, and see if the FB engine is as good/better than the EJ.
I will also add on of the the Subaru/Scion twins. Lets face it, one of those will end up in the fleet at some point.
alblckevrythng says:
11:29 PM, 02/20/12
FRS or BRZ
LASHAWN says:
04:59 AM, 02/21/12
I suggest getting the 2012 Hyundai Azera, 2012 Dodge Durango(both v6/v8), 2012 Dodge Charger(both v6/v8) and 2013 Ford GT500. These are everyday cars that your everday person will buy, something just for the mainstream consumer. Besides, these are what I'm looking at buying by end of year.
peakarach1 says:
10:55 AM, 02/21/12
How about Scion FR-S?
philaburb says:
12:15 PM, 02/21/12
1986 or 87 Audi Quattro Gt coupe.
v8vroom says:
02:17 PM, 02/23/12
Jaguar XF (give the Germans a rest!)
Having a new Fusion Titanium and a 328 at the same time would be interesting. The way you guys have been loading up your cars, the BMW would probably end up at $50k. So the question would be, is the BMW worth the extra $20k over the Ford?
How about project Subaru BRZ? Is it really a great track day toy?
doss1 says:
04:43 PM, 02/28/12
Pick up a 2002 Maserati Coupe. I've been going back and forth on the purchase of this car, and I need objective reasoning not to buy it. You can find a 6 speed manual without the skyhook suspension for under $30 pretty easy. Fuel mileage is dismal, but the sounds of that V8 makes up for it.
landric says:
05:41 PM, 04/ 6/12
I'd like to see:
1) Mazda5 Sport Manual
2) Toyota Prius C
3) Kia Soul
4) Toyota Tacoma 4x4 Reg Cab 5-Speed/4cylinder
5) Honda CR-Z Manual
eliteboi says:
01:37 PM, 04/28/12
YES! I was so happy to see you guys are getting the 12' Beetle Turbo! I hope that you guys do get the 6spd though. We all know already what the 12' Beetle turbo is like with DSG!
Your review on that will be swaying my first brand new car purchase.
Veloster Turbo? I drove in the normal one months ago, nice bang for the buck. Add turbo and it will probably be a winner.
I would say get the Envogue, i'm interested in seeing what everyone thinks of it. I'd go with the 4 door myself