Home

Long-Term Road Tests

Daily updates on our fleet of cars and trucks

2009 BMW M3: Seat Wear Already

M3-seat-1.jpg

After 9,000 miles of use the leather on the seat bolster of the M3's driver's seat is visibly showing wear. Not a huge surprise considering it's impossible to climb in the car without rubbing your derriere across it, but it does seem premature after just 9,000 miles.  

M3-seat-2.jpg

Scott Oldham, Inside Line Editor in Chief @ 9,018 miles 

Categories:

31 Comments

shaddai says:

10:53 AM, 09/18/09

Vacuum that seat! Ugh!

sofaonasock says:

10:58 AM, 09/18/09

Have you tried leather conditioner?

carguy622 says:

11:16 AM, 09/18/09

That is filthy. I think the wear is accelerated a bit on the long term cars. Kind of like dog years.

My 06' TSX with 30,000 miles has pristine leather (then again it's not the highest quality leather). I just condition the leather every month or so. I like the Turtle Wax leather conditioner.

clarkma5 says:

11:21 AM, 09/18/09

Disappointing but I too saw permanent wear on my first GTI's leather seats by just 10,000 miles, despite cleaning and conditioning the seats every time I washed (typically once every 2 to 3 weeks).

It's yet another reason why I prefer cloth. The cloth seats in my 5.5 year old, 50,000 mile VW look practically new still.

adavis2493 says:

11:38 AM, 09/18/09

In my A5, I'm starting to get the usual leather streaks on the seat cushions because of regular use.

In this situation, this is the only time I approve of Leatherette Interior. My old 3-Series with Leatherette had no wear whatsoever at the 80,000mls I sold it at.

indy_mistert says:

11:45 AM, 09/18/09

by 9k miles I probably would have detailed the interior 2x... have you put a drop of conditioner, etc on it?

pyo_s65 says:

11:46 AM, 09/18/09

That's what you get for not conditioning the leather! Serves you right! :D

Jokes aside, the leather does wrinkle fairly quickly and unless treated with the conditioner it could quickly deteriorate into dry cracks. Once a month of Lexol leather should do the trick here. At this point, you best use Leatherique.

louiswei says:

11:48 AM, 09/18/09

That is terrible, my car is almost 3.5 years old now and still no seat wear marks like that.

ahightower says:

11:54 AM, 09/18/09

I don't think it's the creases that are a concern, it's the color wearing off. Conditioner won't help that. This leather should be dyed more deeply. I wonder how much to touch that up, and difficulty of getting a perfect match?

wrinklebump says:

11:57 AM, 09/18/09

This is why leather is worthless. I can think of better things to do than polish the god blessed seats of my car, like get eaten by a mutant rooster

mlevere1992 says:

12:08 PM, 09/18/09

Here has always been a problem with BMW's red leather. It was even worse on the e30 M3. If you would have gotten black or tan, this would have never been an issue.

miraa says:

12:18 PM, 09/18/09

It's patina! Like a knotty pine floor, a well-loved leather jacket, or that perfect pair of Levis. Then again, my favorite jeans have a hole in them. I guess that's what you have to look forward to in your red leather seats.

altimadude00 says:

12:33 PM, 09/18/09

I have cloth seats. They don't wrinkle.

audisport says:

12:37 PM, 09/18/09

Many less expensive cars actually have pleather on the side bolster areas, obviously to save money, but in turn, the seats wear a lot better over time. That looks hideous. Remember that the R8's side bolsters looked similar but at closer to 20k miles I think.

achenator says:

01:02 PM, 09/18/09

I am having the same issue on my black interior 08 with 7500 mi.
I condition regularly with zaino and lexol. The color is wearing off. I thought it was cuz i am fat LOL.

subaru123 says:

01:22 PM, 09/18/09

To keep you commenters happy, I won't post a comment about this post as you all know my view on BMWs.

corollasman says:

01:43 PM, 09/18/09

Just seems too soon for wear.

pengwin says:

02:22 PM, 09/18/09

Vinyl seats dont do this.

slickersdrip says:

03:14 PM, 09/18/09

By 30,000 miles, the side bolster by the door on my SRT-4 literally wore through the leather, the padding, and are down to the wire on one side. The Dodge dealership said I was just having too much wear from getting into and out of the seats to cover it under warranty. I'm 6'4" and 185 pounds, so it's not like I'm barely squeezing myself over the seats...

I rarely have passengers of any type and yet the passenger side is having the same wear. That's truly unacceptable.

bodyblue says:

04:33 PM, 09/18/09

"Leatherette"......What BS call it what it is....VINYL. All that money for the "Ultimate Driving Machine" And you have to pay extra for leather???????? Ummmm how did the leather in your Focus wear?

bkochuk says:

06:01 PM, 09/18/09

see if they cover it under warranty!

roadburner says:

06:38 PM, 09/18/09

After 117,000 miles the leather bolsters on my 1995 3er look better than that. Leather needs to be cleaned and conditioned.

slickersdrip says:

06:51 PM, 09/18/09

+1 at roadburner. It's why you have to moisturize skin some manner as well.

This post did prompt me to remove my shift knob and condition it this evening...

drewsrx says:

10:22 PM, 09/18/09

More trouble for your long-term BMW's, sad!

oftech says:

05:25 AM, 09/19/09

+100 for cleaning and conditioning the leather. 2 years, 38,000 miles and my leather (Black) looks great! Probably because I take care of it and the only person who drives my car is me.

As much as I love leather seats, I must give credit to leatherette (although I refer to it as Pleather) for being able to take any abuse without showing any wear. The only downside is that the vinyl smell can be a bit overwhelming if the car has been in the sun all day.

bodyblue says:

05:34 AM, 09/19/09

Being hot, cold and sweaty is not a downside??? Vinyl sucks for comfort but is great for wear and tear. I cant think of one American car that you can still get vinyl in, except trucks of course.

afty says:

04:36 PM, 09/19/09

@clarkma Agreed on the preference for cloth seats. The cloth seats in my '02 Altima still look new.

achenator says:

06:17 PM, 09/19/09

For the LAST time conditioning does not help. My seat in my 08 looks exactly the same at 7500 miles. I condition every month or so. The color is wearing off.

1487 says:

06:24 AM, 09/21/09

"After 117,000 miles the leather bolsters on my 1995 3er look better than that. Leather needs to be cleaned and conditioned."

No car should show that level of wear after 9k miles. Do you really expect the average owner to condition leather daily just to avoide premature wear? My old car's leather looked likethat after 6 years I only cleaned the seats a few times a year.

redwoodaggie says:

07:43 AM, 09/21/09

When I had a '99 M3, the side bolsters were wearing worse than that at 51K miles when I sold it. Like you said, it's hard to get in without rubbing on the bolsters. The leather in my E46 328 was less soft, but certainly a lot tougher! It had about the same wear, but at 154K miles. The leather in my G8 GT is wearing very well at 9K miles.

mopho says:

07:24 PM, 09/29/09

This is one of the major reasons I actually prefer BMW's standard leatherette. It wears better.

@altimadude00
My car has cloth seats and the bottom left driver's bolster is wrinkled. =/
I swear I'm not overweight.
Well, maybe a little, but in a good way..

Add a comment

Advertisement

Latest Poll

Has reading the Long-Term Road Test Blog helped in your car purchasing decisions?

Recent Posts

Advertisement

Tip the Editors

Got a breaking news tip for the Inside Line editors?

Send it to tips@edmunds.com

Awards

min's Best of the Web award

Past Vehicles

Browse Archives