I don't mean to imply with this entry's title that there's something wrong with our 2008 BMW 135i's suspension. Everything's working fine. But after all these months, this car's ride quality still doesn't feel quite right to me. Well, at least it doesn't feel right to me on the freeways and a lot of the city streets in the LA area.
Every time I get in our 135i, I'm struck by how compliant it wants to be. Its ride isn't just smooth, it's downright soft. But as soon as I hit an expansion joint or an uneven patch of pavement, I realize I'm mistaken. Initially, the suspension compresses in its soft, forgiving manner, but then, a big dose of damping brings it back hard and you feel the brunt of that road imperfection. The sequence gets old after you realize what's happening, and it made my passenger queasy.
To me, the car feels conflicted, like the chassis engineers couldn't decide whether the U.S.-spec BMW 1 Series needed to be a cushy cruiser for people who ordinarily wouldn't buy a BMW, or a full-on sport coupe for people who think the 3 Series has gotten too big and luxurious. So it's both -- and neither.
Given how much engine is in this car, I'd vote for giving it an unapologetically firm, highly controlled ride. Save the cushy stuff for the 128i.
Erin Riches, Senior Editor @ 26,217 miles

carguy622 says:
11:52 AM, 08/12/09
I'll agree with that. Although I wonder if the relatively short wheelbase has anything to do with it?
alexdi says:
11:56 AM, 08/12/09
It sounds more like a lack of suspension travel and variable-rate springs tuned to avoid the bump stops. RFTs, if they're still on the car, wouldn't have helped.
08lr3 says:
12:10 PM, 08/12/09
I can tell big difference in the RFT and non RTF.. but I do like the BMW Perf package tire set I have on for summer. . just sexy on the car me thinks!
louiswei says:
12:16 PM, 08/12/09
Never driven the 135i before but I have the same experience when driving the 328i loaner I got couple weeks ago.
It's not a big deal, at least it's better than the artificial harshness in some cars (yes, Lexus, I am talking about you...). The thing I couldn't stand about BMW is the too-heavy steering.
compliance says:
12:38 PM, 08/12/09
"I'd vote for giving it an unapologetically firm, highly controlled ride. Save the cushy stuff for the 128i."
This would be nice and is a very logical solution, but then you have all the people that want a cushy luxury car who will only buy the version with the highest number on it. Those people would then turn around and complain about the ride. Idiots.
This is why no crossover should ever be marketed as sporty, because it dilutes the term and tricks people into thinking that is what they want. Consumers should be smarter but they are not.
jameswilliard says:
12:56 PM, 08/12/09
Three words: RUN FLAT TIRES
I will never understand how BMW's brilliant engineers are ok with how badly their cars crash over small bumps. I've owned BMW's for over 10 years, including my last two, a 2006 330i and a 2007 335i-both which I purchased new. The newer ones with the runflats hit small bumps hard and to make matters worse its as if the suspension is tuned softer than normal to compensate for this. The BMW ability to magically combine a supple ride with tight cornering has been lost all for the sake of Runflat tires. I just don't understand.
jameswilliard says:
12:58 PM, 08/12/09
Three words: RUN FLAT TIRES
I will never understand how BMW's brilliant engineers are ok with how badly their cars crash over small bumps. I've owned BMW's for over 10 years, including my last two, a 2006 330i and a 2007 335i-both which I purchased new. The newer ones with the runflats hit small bumps hard and to make matters worse its as if the suspension is tuned softer than normal to compensate for this. The BMW ability to magically combine a supple ride with tight cornering has been lost all for the sake of Runflat tires. I just don't understand.
bimmerjay says:
01:09 PM, 08/12/09
Yes, this sounds like case of the RFTs. The ultra-firm sidewalls combined with a very low profile result in quite the impact harshness over bad bumps. I wish BMW would give you a non-RFT tire option.
adavis2493 says:
01:24 PM, 08/12/09
I agree with jameswilliard. Run Flats are seriously the worst thing BMW can do to one of their cars (excluding crappy cup holders). Problem is, My 2007 X3 has a pair of bald Pzero Rosso's on it, which are run flats. They only make three tires for it, 2 of them being Run Flats, while the other is impossible to find (Tirerack doesn't even have it).
hurls65 says:
01:36 PM, 08/12/09
I'm gonna have to agree with jameswilliard... crashing HARD over small bumps and low speed bad roads seems common to a lot of BMWs
blueguydotcom says:
02:22 PM, 08/12/09
RFTs = odd ride. My e90 330i bounced and e90 335i will literally skip over uneven pavement and send massive quakes through the chassis.
RFTs = the devil. I'm only keeping mine as they were brand new when I got the car and I don't want to drop 1k on tires.
roadburner says:
02:24 PM, 08/12/09
The RFTs are the primary problem. My 1995 Club Sport has the M Technic sport suspension and it has a very comfortable ride. For that matter, my 2004 X3 has a suspension calibration that could hardly be called punishing. One of my friends(who has never owned anything but domestic iron) commented on how comfortable the truck's ride was.
drand1 says:
04:17 PM, 08/12/09
It is the run flats. I have had the same experience since I got the car over a year ago. Yesterday I had new tires put on and it is now a totally different experience. It now feels stiffer when it should and more compliant when it hits a bump.
cwc1 says:
05:52 PM, 08/12/09
The other problem I see with the RFTs is that if you want to later swap to non-RFTs, there isn't a well in the sedans & coupes to nicely store the spare, since BMW now deems that as superfluous. Instead, the spare would take up space in the trunk, which is a major drawback. Or you can rely on roadside assistance, which seems too dependent and time consuming to me. I'd rather just the change the tire myself.
07mx5 says:
06:38 PM, 08/12/09
hahaha, i was about to comment, "would this have anything to do with the run-flats?" Apparently the consensus is yes.
bmw should do what mazda does with the mx5. no runflats, no spare, no on-star, just a small bag that has a can of gooo and a phone number.
blueguydotcom says:
09:57 PM, 08/12/09
cwc, I've been driving for 25 years. 1 flat in all those years and it was on my 2003 330i. The spare was fairly useless as the car was essentially impossible to drive with it.
Plenty of sports cars the world over get by without a spare.
mopho says:
10:26 AM, 08/13/09
My experience agrees with the consensus that run-flats noticeably deteriorate the ride quality. I wish BMW would just equip cars with a jack and spare, even if it ends up adding a little bit of weight.
cwc1 says:
05:40 PM, 08/13/09
@blueguydotcom,
I've been driving for roughly the same period of time (28 years) and have only had two to three flat tires that I can recall.
But - if it happens, I'd rather not be stuck. And my 330Ci has a full size spare, so I consider that an advantage and not useless. Did your 330i not come with a full size spare?
bbechtel16 says:
07:35 PM, 08/13/09
"Save the cushy stuff for the 128i."
Hey now, some of us only have hope of affording the 128, and while they need a serious suspension, don't see the need for two turbos and 300 hp if it's going to cost them a couple grand and MPGs.
bimmerjay says:
11:21 PM, 08/13/09
@cwc1,
No E9x (2006+ 3-Series) BMW comes with any sort of a spare or a compartment to hold one. Instead there's a finished storage well in the trunk, which is mostly taken up by the exhaust system in the 335i.
I think both the 128i and 135i should have softer standard suspensions, optional sport suspensions, and a further optional M Sport suspension. You sort of have that choice, but not quite.
fireflyer239 says:
09:27 PM, 08/28/09
RFT problem verified here...and corrected. Just switched to some deliciously lightweight Breyton GTS-R 18" alloys and Michelin non-runflats (Pilot Sport A/S Plus) - problem gone! Now there's a much better relationship between tire and suspension, much more progressive bump absorption. It's as if the RFT's are trying to make up for being overly harsh on the medium size and bigger hits by being overly soft on initial compliance and small stuff, and that just does not work! It hurts initial turn-in response too; the OEM P-Zero RFT's I just got rid of did not have the crisp turn-in of the Goodyear F1 A/S's I had on my 330i, nor that of my new Michelins. Worse, the P-Zero RFT's are summer tires, and supposed to represent the highest-performing segment of tires, while both the others I mention are members of the "ultra high performance all season" segment. I have AAA, BMW Roadside Assistance and my cell phone, along with a bag of trail mix and a Red Bull I keep in the car ,and I feel fine! Down with RFT's!